← Back to Playbooks • Starter Playbook
Restorative Justice Circles
Train volunteer Circle Keepers to facilitate restorative justice processes for youth offenses. By diverting cases from the court system, you prevent criminal records that block college loans, housing, and employment—protecting lifetime earning potential.
What's Inside
Grace UMC & New Waverly UMC — Received UMC Peace with Justice grants ($400–$500) to launch youth diversion programs for first-time offenses
Sample budget: $1,100–$2,500/year (covers Circle Keeper training, supplies, and caregiver support)
90-day plan: Train 3–4 Circle Keepers, partner with schools/courts, facilitate first restorative circle
What Makes This Playbook Distinct
Upstream intervention — Unlike expungement clinics or legal aid (which address records after they exist), Restorative Justice Circles intervene before charges are filed. This prevents criminal records entirely, protecting youth eligibility for federal student loans, housing, and future employment.
What Is Restorative Justice?
Restorative Justice (RJ) is a framework for resolving harm through facilitated dialogue between the person who caused harm, the person harmed, and the community. It replaces punitive criminal prosecution with accountability, healing, and reintegration.
The Core Mechanism
A trained Circle Keeper convenes a circle that includes:
- 1. The youth who committed the offense (e.g., underage alcohol possession, marijuana, shoplifting)
- 2. The person or community harmed (if applicable)
- 3. Family members or community representatives
- 4. The Circle Keeper (facilitator trained in conflict resolution)
The youth takes accountability, the harm is named, and the group collectively designs a plan for repair (community service, apology letters, restitution). If the youth completes the plan, no criminal charge is filed—preserving their clean record.
Church Examples: UMC Peace with Justice Initiative
The United Methodist Church actively funds restorative justice projects through micro-grants ranging from $500 to $2,000. These grants cover Circle Keeper training and program implementation.
Grace UMC & New Waverly UMC
Grace United Methodist Church received $400 and New Waverly UMC received $500 in UMC Peace with Justice grants to launch Restorative Justice Diversion programs for youth. These programs address first-time offenses like underage alcohol possession or marijuana outside of court, keeping youth eligible for federal financial aid and preventing criminal records.
- Grant Amount
- $400–$500 per church
- Program Focus
- Youth diversion for first-time, low-level offenses
- Outcome
- Youth avoid criminal records, retain college loan eligibility
Economic Impact: By diverting a youth from a felony charge, the church preserves the youth's future eligibility for federal student loans (up to $31,000 over 4 years) and employment opportunities worth hundreds of thousands of dollars in lifetime earnings.
Other UMC Recipients (Baltimore-Washington Conference)
- • Mount Zion UMC — $300 for restorative justice training
- • Piney Grove UMC — $500 for community mediation circles
The Economics of Diversion
Cost Avoidance & Human Capital Preservation
Restorative Justice ministries operate on two economic principles: cost avoidance (preventing expensive system processing) and human capital preservation (protecting lifetime earning potential).
System Costs Avoided
Processing a youth through the traditional juvenile justice system involves police time, court clerks, judges, public defenders, and potential detention. The church-based RJ circle relies on trained volunteer Circle Keepers and church facilities—costing a fraction of formal system processing.
Future Earnings Protected
The most significant economic benefit is prevention of a criminal record. By diverting a youth from a felony charge to a restorative circle, the church preserves the youth's future eligibility for:
- ✓ Federal student loans (up to $31,000 over 4 years)
- ✓ Public housing assistance
- ✓ Employment in licensed professions (teaching, nursing, trades)
Recidivism Reduction
Programs like the Neighborhood Restorative Justice Program in Santa Barbara show that restorative processes reduce recidivism. Reduced recidivism translates to lower long-term policing and incarceration costs for the neighborhood.
National Economic Data
- Criminal Record Wealth Loss: Americans with criminal records have lost approximately $370 billion in combined wealth due to employment barriers.
- Per-Person Impact: Clearing a record leads to an average $4,400 annual wage increase (Missouri data). Preventing a record has even greater impact.
Circle Keeper Training: Your Core Investment
The core economic asset in Restorative Justice ministries is the volunteer Circle Keeper—a trained facilitator who can mediate conflict and guide restorative processes. Unlike expungement clinics (which need lawyers) or bail funds (which need cash), RJ ministries need trained time.
Training Requirements & Costs
Training Duration
Becoming a Circle Keeper requires significant training: workshops typically run 3-4 days (20-30 hours) and cost between $350 and $450 per participant. Churches often subsidize this training through grants.
Volunteer Commitment
A volunteer panelist typically commits to a 2-year term, contributing 2-3 hours per month. This includes circle facilitation, prep time, and follow-up with participants.
Economic Value of Volunteer Labor
The Independent Sector values a volunteer hour at $34.79. A restorative justice session involving two facilitators and two community members for three hours represents nearly $420 in donated labor per circle.
Annual Value: A robust church ministry running 12 circles/year donates approximately $5,000 in skilled conflict resolution labor to the community.
The Cost of Burnout
Dealing with trauma, crime, and conflict is emotionally exhausting. High burnout rates lead to volunteer turnover, necessitating a constant cycle of recruitment and retraining—which increases operating costs.
Sustainable ministries must budget for "care for the caregivers"—retreats, counseling, and debriefing sessions—to maintain their human capital stock.
Sample Budget: Restorative Justice Ministry (Annual)
| Item | Detail | Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Circle Keeper Training | 3-4 day workshop (20-30 hours) for 3-4 volunteers | $1,200–$1,800 |
| Meeting Space | Church fellowship hall (in-kind) | In-Kind |
| Materials & Supplies | Circle guidelines, reflection cards, talking pieces | $200–$400 |
| Volunteer Stipends | Optional: $25/circle x 12 circles/year | $0–$600 |
| Caregiver Support | Quarterly retreats to prevent burnout | $400–$800 |
| Total First Year | $1,800–$3,600 | |
| Volunteer Value: 2 facilitators × 3 hours × 12 circles × $34.79/hr = $2,500 in-kind labor annually | ||
Year 2 Recurring Cost: $1,100–$2,500 (no re-training needed unless adding new Circle Keepers)
Your 90-Day Sprint: Train Circle Keepers
Restorative Justice requires upfront investment in volunteer training, but the long-term impact—preventing criminal records and preserving lifetime earning potential—is transformative.
Days 1-30: The Candidates
- • Identify 3-5 members with conflict resolution skills (social workers, teachers, counselors)
- • Apply for UMC Peace with Justice grant ($500-$2,000) or similar denominational funds
- • Register for Restorative Justice training through local coalition
Days 31-60: The Training
- • Complete 3-4 day Circle Keeper certification (20-30 hours)
- • Cost per person: $350-$450 (subsidized by grant)
- • Practice facilitation in safe church environment with role-plays
Days 61-90: The Launch
- • Partner with local schools or juvenile court for referrals
- • Offer diversion services for first-time youth offenses
- • Facilitate first circle with co-facilitation for support
Key Metric:
Number of youth diverted from criminal records (goal: 5-10 in first year)
Economic Impact at a Glance
Record Prevention
Diverting youth from felony charges preserves eligibility for federal student loans (up to $31,000 over 4 years) and employment in licensed professions worth hundreds of thousands in lifetime earnings.
System Cost Savings
Processing a youth through traditional justice system is expensive (police, courts, detention). RJ circles use volunteer labor, costing a fraction of formal system processing.
Recidivism Reduction
Restorative processes reduce repeat offenses, lowering long-term policing and incarceration costs for neighborhoods. Santa Barbara programs show measurable recidivism reduction.
Volunteer Asset Value
Circle Keepers provide skilled conflict resolution labor valued at $420 per 3-hour session. A church running 12 circles/year donates ~$5,000 in labor annually.
Ready to Launch Restorative Justice Circles?
Restorative Justice Circles are upstream interventions that prevent criminal records before they exist—protecting lifetime earning potential for youth and reducing long-term system costs.